On the disconnect between artisans and enjoyers
There’s been a resurgence of discourse pertaining to niche music, movies, books, video games and anime.
I find this interesting because the algorithm (youtube shorts. Yes, I know its bad for me) has pushed this onto me and I find it extremely irritating.
To quickly summarize the core issue:
-
A lot of people are into various types of media, and join in person (or online) groups discussing it.
-
There are times when the discussion starts to take an extremely nerdy or technical direction - or the piece of media is considered "disturbing" or "strange".
-
The "new" person gets annoyed at this. Why don’t they discuss something "fun"? Or something that’s "popular"?
-
The rest of the group gets annoyed at this new person for not "getting it", or being unwilling to engage.
-
This causes friction. If the new people outnumber the rest, then the dynamics are going to shift.
-
The new people call the others weird gatekeepers.
-
Everyone who’s been in the hobby calls everyone else stupid for not getting it. …
-
rinse and repeat.
This isn’t a new phenomenon. In fact, I would expect adults to experience this multiple times in their life.
I like movies. But if you were to put me in a room where people talk about 1940s movies like casablanca or the maltese falcon and the cinematic language - I’d be awkwardly quiet.
I like music. Metal music, in particular. Again, if you brought up people talking about some 100 monthly average listeners musician on spotify, I’d be unable to add anything to the conversation. Same thing if you brought up music theory, or other types of artistic analysis.
Now - I LOVE video games. And I can tell you everything about my favorite ones. I can talk for hours about the differences in development culture between Japanese and American teams, how musicians a
I think it’s extremely strange for people to enter
I think the core distinction comes down between being an "artisian" and an "enjoyer".
Enjoyer = someone experiences media primarily as a passive consumer. These are people with rich, active lives who want to share the passion they have for a particular piece of media. They’re not necessarily interested in learning more or engaging with it on a critical, complex manner. They just want to enjoy it.
Artisan = someone who experiences media in a critical, active way. These are people with rich, active lives who want to share the passion they have for the ARTISTRY of the media format as a whole. They gain enjoyment through detailed learning and understanding.
I think this is the crux of the issue.
Do you enjoy socializing about media? Or are you more interested in deeper discussion only, and don’t care much for conversing? Do you find the knee-jerk thoughts of people to be irritating and annoying? Do you find people who spend time dissecting the sound of a guitar’s tone, or the musical scale of a song to be pretentious?
And here’s the most important question:
Do you have the emotional intelligence to recognize that other people aren’t like you? That this is a diverse world, with diverse tastes?